CANBERRA, ACT, Nov. 17 -- The Treasurer of Australia issued the following transcript:
Jim Chalmers:
It's a really big and busy week. Today we have the opportunity to update the ASIC conference on our very substantial progress that we're making on our deregulation agenda, particularly when it comes to cutting compliance costs. I'll also be meeting today with UK pension funds, which collectively manage something like $4trillion in funds, to talk about attracting more investment here in Australia. Tomorrow, in Melbourne, I'll be making an announcement about the next steps when it comes to superannuation reform. We're also working very closely with the business community and with regulators on the next steps when it comes to our deregulation agenda. Obviously, we are working very, very hard with the cabinet colleagues and others to make the decisions over the coming weeks which underpin the mid‑year economic update, which will be released before the end of the year.
We've got no shortage of advantages in our economy, but we've got some serious challenges as well. Inflation, productivity and global economic volatility will be the major focuses of the mid‑year economic update, which I'll release with Katy Gallagher before the end of the year. We acknowledge that there are serious pressures and serious challenges in our economy, but we've also got a lot going for us as well, and I'll have the chance this morning to provide a stocktake on our economy at a time of very substantial global volatility as well.
Our productivity agenda is really important. We are making meaningful and methodical progress on deregulation and cutting compliance costs in particular. There is always more work to do on deregulation and cutting compliance costs. And Katy Gallagher and I are already engaged with the business community on the next steps when it comes to deregulation and cutting compliance costs, working closely and engaging with the business community and also obviously the regulator community as well.
Our political opponents are talking about cutting red tape, we're actually cutting red tape. A $10billion‑plus saving for businesses each year when our budget package for productivity is fully implemented. That's our focus right now, at the same time as we're working closely with businesses and others on the second stage of deregulation and cutting compliance costs between now and the Budget in May.
Journalist:
Treasurer, do you accept that a large portion of the public and even some of your own Labor colleagues have lost faith in your ability to do your job well?
Chalmers:
I don't accept that characterisation. When you're pushing difficult reforms through the parliament, obviously that invites a lot of feedback. What we've seen in recent months is the inevitable consequences of a Treasurer pushing difficult reforms through the parliament. Now, my predecessors have acknowledged the problems at the intersection of the tax system and the housing market, in particular, and done nothing about them. We've taken some difficult decisions. You can see that reflected in the polls, you can see that reflected from time to time in the newspaper coverage, but it's really important that we press ahead.
Journalist:
So how do you rate your job? How do you rate yourself in the job that you're doing?
Chalmers:
That's not for me to do.
Journalist:
Don't you have insight into what you're achieving?
Chalmers:
What we're doing, what we're progressing, is the most substantial productivity package in decades. The most substantial tax reform package in decades. Managing the Australian economy with all of its advantages and all of its challenges at a time of very substantial global economic volatility. I'll leave the commentary, and I'll leave the ratings, for others.
Journalist:
Treasurer, in the mid‑year update you mentioned, are there going to be deep cuts to public spending, and is the economy strong enough to support any cuts to public spending?
Chalmers:
There will be more savings in the mid‑year budget update before the end of the year. We've made responsible savings in every single one of our 8 budget updates so far, and there will be more savings in the ninth. We are working very closely with the colleagues to finalise the savings package for the mid‑year update. It will take into consideration all of the pressures in our economy and especially the inflationary pressures in our economy right now.
Journalist:
Treasurer, are you still in talks with the Greens about the government's proposed changes to the capital gains tax?
Chalmers:
Of course, and those negotiations and those discussions will continue until the legislation is passed by the Senate. I've learned not to pre‑empt or make assumptions about outcomes in the Senate. We engage in good faith with the crossbench in the Senate and with others to pass our very ambitious legislative package, and those discussions are ongoing.
Journalist:
Treasurer, are you willing to sacrifice religious schools and sporting groups to get your trusts tax past the Greens?
Chalmers:
I'm obviously aware of some of the proposals that they put to us publicly and privately, and we're in discussions with the Greens about that. But we haven't changed our position on the exemptions in the arrangements that we announced earlier in the year. As I said before, in response to your colleague's question, we engage in good faith. We've made it clear what we're up for and what we're not up for in terms of that discussion. We hope to see this legislation passed because this legislation, at its core, is all about making the tax system fairer. It's about funding tax cuts for workers, it's about making the housing market fairer for first‑home buyers and young people in particular. Our objectives are clear. No one party controls the Senate on its own, and so these discussions that we have with the crossbench and with others are just a necessary part of trying to get difficult legislation through the upper house.
Journalist:
Treasurer, just to follow on that, it sounds like you'll find another route. You're not willing to make concessions on sporting clubs and religious schools? You'll find another route then to get these taxes through?
Chalmers:
I guess the point that I'm making is that there are a number of issues being discussed beyond those that you have asked me about. We've made our views on those particular matters pretty clear. But we recognise that no one party controls the Senate on its own, and so these discussions that we have with minor parties and others on the crossbench are a necessary part of getting our ambitious tax reforms legislated. We'll engage with them in good faith and not through the media.
Journalist:
There's a lot of momentum for Allegra Spender's version of the CGT tax and those changes. Is that something you'll consider? Is it part of negotiations with the Greens?
Chalmers:
It's not been part of the negotiations with the Greens. That's the first point. I want to say this about Allegra Spender's proposal. Allegra wrote to me about it, we sat down, and we had a longish discussion about it. I got Treasury advice on it. I have a lot of respect for Allegra and the contribution that she makes, but there are important reasons why I don't think the model that she's put forward is the right model.
I've written back to her. I did that a couple of days ago and I indicated when I did write back to her with a proper factual analytical response, including the views of the Treasury, that I would be releasing that letter in due course. Out of respect to her, I wanted to give her a few days with that letter before I release it. But you should anticipate that I'll put that letter out in the next day or 2, and that will run through the major reasons why we don't intend to go down that path.
To summarise those reasons: the proposal that Allegra has put forward in the view of the Treasury is unlikely to be simpler, unlikely to be fairer, unlikely to lead to a more productive economy. In fact, in its view, it's more likely to be more complex, it could lead to higher taxes on some innovative start‑ups, and we think that there are more integrity issues with what has been proposed. I say all of that respectfully. I think it's a good thing that Allegra and others have views in this regard, and I have engaged with her in a very respectful way, including writing back to her in some detail.
There are very good reasons why we have focused the carve‑outs and concessions on small businesses and on innovative start‑ups with positive spillovers in our economy, and that's the way that we intend to proceed.
Journalist:
The ATO has paused the nudge‑letter scheme for the super payments. Do you think that the Commissioner should apologise for the issue surrounding that?
Chalmers:
I'm not going to tell him to do that. The ATO manages the day‑to‑day collection of tax and the superannuation obligations of business at arm's length from government. We have made it very clear that all engagement with businesses needs to be respectful and needs to be constructive. Now, as I understand it, the letters that you're referring to were not collection letters, they were not penalty notices. They were encouraging businesses to engage with the ATO about their obligations.
But, regardless, we've spoken to the ATO about improving those processes. We think that that's important that those processes be improved. As I understand it, the ATO has now paused those letters while they improve those processes. As I said, we make it clear privately and publicly the ATO has got a difficult and important job to do. We respect that. We ask them to engage with businesses in a respectful and a constructive way and part of that means having another look at these letters that have gone out.
Journalist:
Home‑loan lending to investors has fallen. Are you concerned about that when you're trying to get more homes built?
Chalmers:
A couple of things are happening in the housing market simultaneously. There are a number of factors at play, whether it's interest rate changes, broader economic conditions, and the changes that we've made at the intersection of the housing market and the tax system. There's no one factor that is leading to the volatility that we're seeing in the housing market.
But despite that, we are seeing some encouraging progress. For example, when it comes to loans for investment in new builds, that's come up. That's a good thing. We also see in that Commonwealth Bank data that lending for first‑home buyers has almost doubled at the same time as lending for investors has almost halved. So, you can see the beginnings of some of that progress but there's a long way to go.
I encourage people to judge our tax reforms and the housing market - as Australians do - over a period of years rather than a period of the last few months. There is a lot of volatility in the housing market and that has more than one source.
Journalist:
Treasurer, the ABC understands the number of backpackers allowed to stay in the third year will be increased from 5,000, the limit you imposed. How much do you think that limit should be increased by?
Chalmers:
First of all, Burkey's got more to say about this later on in the day, and obviously I don't want to front‑run that. I know that Tony has been doing an absolute mountain of work in a very consultative and diligent way to make sure that we strike the right balance here when it comes to managing numbers down in the migration system at the same time as we recognise the essential role of temporary workers in parts of our economy, including in parts of our regional economy.
A lot of our regional members have been working closely with Tony as well. So, I wanted to pay tribute to him for the work that he's been doing and the consultation that he's been doing. Out of respect for him, I'm not going to front‑run his announcement.
Migration has got a really important role to play in our economy. It can continue to play that important role even as we manage the numbers down, as we have been doing. Numbers are down almost 50percent from their peak. That is a deliberate outcome from the government. We can do that at the same time as we recognise that there are legitimate needs in some areas, and Tony will be responding to that later in the day.
Journalist:
Do you think you will still be Treasurer come election time, or have you become a liability to Labor's election chances?
Chalmers:
Yes to the first part of the question. When it comes to the second part of the question, it's the same answer I gave to you at the start of this press conference. I don't spend a lot of time dwelling on the commentary or the politics of what we're trying to achieve here. I understand that when you're embarking on big, ambitious reform- particularly economic reform, especially tax reform- that none of that is easy. I knew that going in and the reason I'm proceeding with it is not because it's easy but because it's the right thing to do. I'll leave the commentary on me or on internal politics to others.
Journalist:
Your state Labor colleagues, though, are saying that the federal brand under yourself and Anthony Albanese has become so toxic they're going to have to distance themselves at the state election. What's your response to that?
Chalmers:
I haven't been focused on them. I've been focused on doing the job that I've been asked to do. Reforming the tax system, managing the economy in the context of a difficult global environment - that's my focus. I'll leave it to others to focus on that kind of commentary.
Thanks very much.
Disclaimer: Curated by HT Syndication.